Science and Inquiry, Fall 2005

You can view this site just like any web site. If you want to be able to edit it, you must register. Once you have a WikiName and password, all you have to do is click the edit link above. Here is a list of TWiki TextFormattingRules.

Review Sessions
Room: Chavez 111
Wednesday 12/14	8–9 p.m.	David
Thursday 12/15	5–6 p.m.	Dan
Thursday 12/15	8–9 p.m.	Will
Note: you can go to any session you choose (not only your TA's)

Syllabus

SuggestedTopicsfortheFirstPaper2005

SuggestedTopicsfortheSecondPaper2005

MidtermFormat

MidtermCurve

FinalFormat

Lecture Notes

FirstDayF2005

IntroductionChapter1

ABriefandEccentricHistoryofScience

ABriefandEccentricHistoryofPhilosophicalPrecursorstoLogicalPositivism

SomePhilosophicalDistinctions

LogicPlusEmpiricism

ProblemswithLogicalPositivism

ProblemswithLogicalEmpiricism

ProblemsaboutInductionandConfirmation

PopperFalsificationism

KuhnNormalScience

KuhnRevolutionaryScience

LakatosLaudanFeyerabendTwoProcess

SociologyofScience

FeministEpistemologyandScienceStudies

WhatIsNaturalism?

ObservationIsTheoryLaden

SocialStructureofScience

ScientificRealism

ScientificExplanation

MuddyPaste

---

Collins and Pinch

Collins and Pinch are the sort of sociologists that I have been criticizing so harshly. As an example, they talk on p. 2 about "the invention of germs." That is bizarre. If germs were "invented" when they say they were, then the Black Plague was not caused by germs (since they hadn't been invented yet) and the disease, which is still with us, known as Bubonic Plague, which we have learned to control very effectively isn't the same disease, and so the fact that the Black Plague was controlled by the same methods, and the fact that the germ was isolated from people with the same symptoms and etiology of disease are all just coincidences.

So, why am I using their book? First of all, they have a pretty mild case of social constructivism. Second, and this is the main thing, if you want to know what it is like to do science in the social and laboratory context in which it is done, the only people who try to find out are sociologists, and (the symmetry principle) they are just as interested in failures as successes, which is important to get a balanced picture.

EdibleKnowledge

SpecialandGeneralRelativity

GermsSterilitySpontaneousGeneration

GravitationalRadiation

---

Darwin

OriginoftheTheoryofEvolution

OriginofSpecies

---

Papers Are Due Wednesday.

Final Is Friday, 16 December 11:00 A.M.–1:00 P.M.,
201 Physics and Atmospheric Sciences Building. Please bring bluebooks.

---

ScienceandInquiryFall2004

-- ShaughanLavine - 19 Aug 2005